Local Temporary Workers Concerned
By Sara Stewart, Reporter
By
Sara Stewart
Story Created:
Jul 2, 2008 at 12:21 PM CDT
Story Updated:
Jul 3, 2008 at 6:58 AM CDT
Temporary work companies arrived almost immediately after the floods.
They're hiring people on a day-to-day basis to clean out businesses like Smulekoff's downtown.
But they also brought people with them to do the work.
Now, some local people here are concerned they're losing jobs because of that.
First come, first to work means starting at five in the morning.
Men and women from in-state, out-of-state, and out-of-the country come here all looking for the same thing.
"I need to find a job. These guys are coming in, trying to take our jobs away,” says Tina Struchen.
Tina Struchen and her friends lost their jobs in the flood, now they're trying desperately to find work.
And failing.
“They keep telling me come back tomorrow,” she says.
The clean-up agencies say the people they bring initially are more skilled in flood cleanup than day-laborers and that now, most of them are gone and they're hiring local,but that's not entirely the case.
"In Pennsylvania is no work. So i'm coming from here I'm coming from work," says Juan Gomez.
Juan Gomez and these workers are paid one-hundred dollars a day for eight hours of work. That's 12 dollars an hour; well above minimum wage.
"Are they legal?”
“I filled out I-9 forms for all the people that are here which was an arduous task. I reviewed all their alien green cards, making sure they were supposed to be here. If they weren't I sent them away," says Russell
"I'm mexican.
Are you a citizen of the states?
Yeah," says Gomez.
Either way, people like Tina Struchen says she's frustrated people are taking jobs she needs.
“It kind of upsets me. We should get the jobs first I think,” says Struchen.
And that search will get more difficult as these jobs wrap up.
One company that hired 200 people now needs only 70.
Recovery Construction says it expects to clean out Smulekoff's for at least another eight days.
The price tag on that job is around three-hundred-thousand-dollars.
That's only for cleaning up, not for reconstruction.
KCRG-TV9's Position on Commenting |
User Agreement
The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of KCRG-TV9. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.
Thursday, Jul 3 at 2:37 PM Concerned wrote ...
Are we not going through enough stress and to just show negative on everything that is happening what is wrong with us. Can we not appreciate 1 moment to breath or thank the people that can & have done the work.Are we all so shallow we have forgotten to be thankful just a little bit. What happened to coming together in a time of crisis. C'mon we are all brothers and sisters should skin color or race really matter.Some people are not getting paid how greedy and lazy we have all become
Thursday, Jul 3 at 2:35 PM JMT wrote ...
Just being out and about lately I've seen businesses with signs in the windows saying they're hiring. I can't remember where right now but I'll post them here as I find them. Arby's on Collins Road might have been one. If everybody that knows of places hiring posts them here maybe those local people losing out on the disgusting jobs of cleaning up toxic waste can apply for one of these more permanent jobs.
Thursday, Jul 3 at 2:02 PM Complain wrote ...
Oh, quit complaining. There are plenty of jobs out there, just try a little harder ...or get an education...seriously, are there that many uneducated iowans? I'm embarassed.
Thursday, Jul 3 at 12:40 PM What wrote ...
"These illegals don't spend all their pay in the states, they send it home accross the border. And they sure don't pay taxes. Most on welfare here too!" THANK YOU FOR THE FACTS. Im with stupid. ->
Thursday, Jul 3 at 12:22 PM A former HR employee wrote ...
I used to work for human resources at a large co here in CR and we used to always require I-9 forms. Why is it a problem to have to fill out a form? Got something to hide?
Thursday, Jul 3 at 8:51 AM From 3:11 to hiring manager wrote ...
You are absolutly right and I admit I was SO WRONG! W9's are filled out for the first $600 for "casual" and I9's are filled out for regular time employees. Thank you for correcting me.
Thursday, Jul 3 at 8:36 AM THE DUDE wrote ...
I USED TO FEEL THE SAME AS MOST. WHY ARE WE LETTING THESE PEOPLE TAKE OUR JOBS? HOWEVER SINCE THE LATTEST TURN OF EVENTS, I DEFINATLY SEE THINGS A LITTLE DIFFERENT. OUR FAMILY LOST ONE OF OUR PROPERTIES,AND WE HAD A LIST OF PEOPLE TO HELP TEAR OUT EVERYTHING. HOWEVER NO ONE SHOWED UP. I UNDERSTAND THEY ALL ARE VOLINTEERS, BUT IF YOU SAY YOUR GONNA DO SOMETHING DO IT!!!!! I'V NOTICED THE WORK ETHIC OF AMERICANS HAVE TOOK A TURN FOR THE WORSE. IM AT A POINT WHERE IF YOUR WILLING TO WORK YOUR HIRED
Thursday, Jul 3 at 8:11 AM Kelli wrote ...
Who cares who's doing the cleanup! As long as they area paying taxes. Local people knew approx. two weeks ago to apply for work paying $10.00 per hour. What took them soo long to apply? Shut up.
Thursday, Jul 3 at 7:47 AM Anonymous wrote ...
You People need to get a life.There are black & white people that set at home and get welfare.that won't work would rather set on there a## and live off of us,and you worry about afew Mexicans taking our jobs!! Whatever Aleast they want to work and not set on there a##.Keep up the good work.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 10:37 PM Meatpacking - Flood Clean-Up wrote ...
Does anyone else see the irony in the fact that ICE just had this huge raid in Iowa to crack down on illegals and now the floods literally brought hundreds of "suspect" illegals back? I do have to thank these people for their hard work, whether they are legal or not, they are working hard at jobs many wouldn't take. For those of you looking for work, there are help wanted signs up all over town. Lindale has an Amana Maytag kiosk where they are recruiting employees in the mall. Good Luck!
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 9:16 PM anonymous wrote ...
I think if Tina really wanted a job she could find one if she tried. Go to one of the temp agencies here that had a ad in the paper for flood cleanup. The workers down town work very hard and in deplorable conditions and we should be thankful to them istead of complaining about them!
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 8:18 PM Me wrote ...
To abreiviation (or however you spelled it), please learn how to spell you make us all look like morons. FEMA has nothing to do with hiring people to do the work. People need to get off the blame FEMA for everything kick, they are working their butts off for us. They are humans just like us, only they have seen disaster after disaster, and they still show up time angain to help people. They leave their families and homes for god knows how long to come here to a bunch of ungrateful people.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 6:42 PM hiring manager wrote ...
3:11 I don't know where you got your information but no matter where you work it is a state law to fill out an I-9 BEFORE starting to work. Look at the comment biz sense wrote. That is just what the form states about who has to fill out this form. Nowhere on this form does it state that if an employee only makes a certain amount of money than they do not need to fill one out. The information that does state that is your W-4 and that is only about filing requirements at the end of the year.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 6:17 PM thank you wrote ...
thank you. illegal or not.... for the hard work that every single one of you are doing.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 4:44 PM whiteguy wrote ...
These illegals don't spend all their pay in the states, they send it home accross the border. And they sure don't pay taxes. Most on welfare here too!
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 4:26 PM TERRI@INTERNISTS PC wrote ...
I FEEL THAT LOCAL PEOPLE SHOULD BE EMPLOYED FIRST THESE PEOPLE HERE THAT LOST JOBS ETC NEED TO WORK TOO NOT JUST THE OUT OF TOWNERS
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 4:23 PM ALLEGED MOM wrote ...
I have also worked, and they bring a "crew" with them. Feel that they are doing there part to higher local people. But they also feel that there crew is more reliable. But I agree with the one's that are displaced should have first glance, and then because some are female, they worked harder then the men. But I did not file a i-9 so what they are talking about. Is not true. But it is hard and yes alot would not come back and of course the the company is looking at the bottom line.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 4:07 PM Got time wrote ...
So you got time to be interviewed by KCRG but not to show up early enough to get the job . Wow, sounds like you're giving it your all.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 3:37 PM just be glad wrote ...
just be glad they are here to do the job and willing to do it. the reason they bring in people is because quite honestly most locals wouldn't last more than a day doing what these people are doing or work in the conditions they are working in. Quite honestly they are not afraid of hard work in poor conditions. I think we should be glad of anyone willing to work under these conditions and not be too picky about it. At least the work is getting done. I thank them for their help!
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 3:36 PM Green Card Competitor wrote ...
Remember this next time before you vote (or when you get around to voting for the first time). I'm in IT and have to compete with the green cards that our government freely gives out by the hundred thousands, so know you know how I feel.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 3:13 PM Get Real wrote ...
Lemme get this sraight...I'm an employer, need a clean-up crew now....So, here's someone standing in front of me willing and capable to work, but I'm 'sposed to offer the work to people that are sitting home waiting for...what?
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 3:11 PM To Cindy at 1:00 pm wrote ...
I-9 forms are filled out for what is called "casual labor" It is for people who work on a temporary basis like the folks who are doing the flood clean up. Usually these forms are filled out and used until the workers have made $600. At that point w-9's are filled out and taxes are then taken out of the checks. I have noticed a hiring freese in the area and think that if the locals want to do the work they should be allowed. IMO they would do a better job because this is their community too.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 3:10 PM sparx69 wrote ...
What about the City of Cedar Rapids telling us to keep the spending local? Maybe they should take their own advise!!They even have a commercial with Lee Clancey telling us to spend locally.. Well, take a drive downtown and tell me how many local companies and/or local residents are actually doing the work! I think we should all be doing our part and keeping it local. I wish everyone the best and will be praying for you. Peace
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 3:09 PM Get Real wrote ...
To yeah right and oh please YOU DON"T KNOW WHAT PEOPLE ARE WILLING TO DO TO SUPPORT THEIR FAMILIES so back off I bet both of you are sitting in dry houses going to your job everyday don't be so quick with your bs comments
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:59 PM The flood gates wrote ...
I guess the flood gates opened in cedar rapids and brought the mexicans in by boat!!! Keep them in CR and do not let them into iowa city
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:53 PM GM wrote ...
These companys are not required to hire locals. They showed up with their own work force that they knew wouldn't flake out because the work sucks. It sucks the city was flooded but these companys specialize in disasters like this and just because you were affected doesn't mean your are entitled to a job. Exspecially if your not qualified.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:45 PM Up-Set wrote ...
Excuse Me, KCRG and whoever ealse...I have seen allot of the workers, and don't tell me they are more qualified than we are..What an insult..The companies that are coming in their fancy trucks only hire people to come here with them so they can get the handouts that are going around, and take away wages that need to be earned by "OUR OWN" displaced people..NOT OUTSIDERS...Some of these people need to support their own families, and pay their bills, not some outsider to take food away from US!!!
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:17 PM spell check wrote ...
they spell her name strooken and struchen in back to back sentences?!!?
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:08 PM Aggie wrote ...
So what I'm hearing now is that these folks displaced by the flooding not only lost their homes but their jobs as well. What is our local government doing about this? Or have they just closed their eyes and don't want to rock the boat? They have to know what is going on - it is quite obvious to all concerned.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:07 PM it's all about oil wrote ...
it's all about oil, they don't have to use as many vehicles to transport the illegals as they do other people, cause they can fit 500 in a school bus
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:05 PM I DID! wrote ...
to yeah right and please: i did do the work thank you very much, so don't sit there in your air conditioned office and cushy leather chair and say that those of us on here wouldn't go out and do the work because i did, i worked outside quaker oats in the 85 degree heat when all the work started
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:02 PM biz sense wrote ...
To Cindy, The I-9 is nothing new, every job should make you fill one out. Directly from the I-9... What Is the Purpose of This Form? The purpose of this form is to document that each new employee (both citizen and non-citizen) hired after November 6, 1986 is authorized to work in the United States. When Should the Form I-9 Be Used? All employees, citizens and noncitizens, hired after November 6, 1986 and working in the United States must complete a Form I-9.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 2:01 PM Anonymous wrote ...
Why doesn't Smulekoff's hire their own employees to help with the clean-up instead they are out of work too.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:49 PM Abreiveation wrote ...
FEMA Find Every Mexican Available
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:38 PM Just a thought wrote ...
If these are first come first serve jobs. I would say to Tina she needs to get at the job sight as early as possible.As the saying goes the early bird gets the worm. The employers do not care where you migrate in from as long as the work gets done.Good luck!!!
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:34 PM Annoyed wrote ...
I think it is horrible that they are giving the jobs to people who don't live here. It is stupid. The people who lost their jobs should have been offered first.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:32 PM old guy wrote ...
Ithink that this is a job for ICE> If in fact they are hiring illegals then they have broken several federal LAWS and some state laws. You can contact the attorney''s general's office in Des Moines as well as the Governers office and let them know your concerns. If the City of CR does not want to assist you in this matter then you should take it up with the state and federal goverment. yes you should be offered the jobs first...... If they dont see that then that company should be asked to leave
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:31 PM I Don't Speak Spanish wrote ...
Where did all the Mexicans come from so fast? Are they more experienced at wading through muddy water, or simply less expensive and available? English seems to be the second language downtown at the moment... I agree that locals should get the first crack at tearing down and reconstructing their city.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:28 PM messed up wrote ...
i worked one day for one of these temps. i'm local and wanted to help out. i worked with three illegals (they told me so) and cleaned out a flooded out bank. the work was hard, and it smelled horrific. and worse yet, the agency scammed me for the time i worked! i filed a complaint, but i don't think anything will come of it. kcrg, do an investigation on these crooks! b/c of my awful experience, i refuse to help out again until things change.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:22 PM YeahRight wrote ...
If you think you would really go down and do the work that these people are doing, as hard as they are doing it, for 8 hours a day, for $12 an hour, you're wrong. I've managed people who can't come to a job where they sit on their comfy parts all day in air conditioning (That doesn't smell like rotting fish) and couldn't get people to have better than 90% - 95% attendance. I'll bet my job that the crews I saw working would outperform 99% of the people that are "looking".
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:20 PM Get a permenant job wrote ...
I would spend less time trying to latch on to a temporary job and more time trying to get a permanent one. I know it is terrifying to be without a job but after the temp job is done you're back in the same proverbial boat again. Good luck to all the displaced workers out there.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 1:00 PM Cindy wrote ...
I can feel the pain as my husband is not working because his building was flooded as well. Unemployment is available through the state for workers displaced due to the flood...Tina should check into that. I'm not sure why an individual has to fill out I-9 forms when they can prove they are a US Citizen - is that something new?
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 12:50 PM PLEASE wrote ...
There are few poeple around here who want to do this kind of work. I am sure they would start and quit in the same day.
Wednesday, Jul 2 at 12:37 PM interesting wrote ...
so if a "legal" citizen can get 12 dollars an hr what are they paying the local people who LOST their jobs due to this flood? those who lost their jobs should be offered the positions first
Add a comment
Most Popular