Poor Immigration Enforcement Blamed in Fatal Crash

By: Claire Kellett, Anchor/Reporter

By Claire Kellett

MARSHALLTOWN - Mona and Merrell Kilborn praise the work of ICE agents handling the raid in Postville, saying they are simply enforcing the laws of the United States. This Marshalltown couple isn't against large populations of people from other countries being in the U-S. Their objection is when people live here illegally.

To Mona and Merrell Kilborn, the moral debate about illegal immigration ends with only one answer. It's wrong, period.

"I am appalled no one seems to bat an eye that so many people are here illegally and very little is done about it," says Mona Kilborn.

The Kilborn's quest to do something about it became more personal last October. An illegal immigrant driving an SUV with a fake license ran a stop sign in town and broadsided their van. Mona's 90-year-old mother died on impact. Her father spent a lot of time in the hospital's intensive care unit. And Merrell broke his back.

"I am reminded every day what happened to me and to us," says Merrell Kilborn.

Painful memories the Kilborns say would not have been made if more state and federal laws were in place to crack down on illegal immigrants. The woman behind this wheel was a repeated rule-breaker.

"The woman who hit us was a convicted felon who had already been adjudicated in court for meth and child endangerment and was charged with serious assault," says Mona.

The Kilborns can't get a clear answer from authorities why the woman was ever released, or why it took the loss of their loved one to send an illegal immigrant back to Mexico. What they do know is the process to become legal is lengthy but legitimate.

"We've adopted internationally. We know what it takes to get into the US, and it's not easy, but we followed the rules," says Mona.

And the Kilborns say so should everyone else. They have been in touch with local, state, and national leaders. They recently worked with a state lawmaker on a bill that would prevent illegal immigrants from bailing themselves out of jail and would punish employers who hire illegal immigrants. They say it passed the House this passed legislative session, but not the Senate. They plan to push the bill again next year.

Friday, May 16 at 11:12 PM cwa7148 wrote ...

To the comment If you dont want them here than why dont you work there jobs maybe you might start thinking different about them and the work they do. I DID THE JOBS THAT THEY DO ( CONSTRUCTION} UNTIL MY WAGES GOT SO LOW THAT I COULD NOT SUPPORT MY FAMILY. I have friends that have lost their lost their jobs, their businesses and for what to support a bunch of law breakers. Come off your high horse and try to really have a clue of what is really going on.

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 16 at 10:04 AM Help! wrote ...

As a human being simply trying to make a living, I could use a better life too. It's always been a dream of mine as well. But as a LEGAL citizen, my options seem limited. So what laws can I break to help ME achieve a better life, and what activist groups etc can I count on for assistance?

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 16 at 1:07 AM john wrote ...

Hey No Name, If I could go to Canada and send my money back here to the states and support my ENTIRE extended family I'd work "their" jobs too.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 7:48 PM D wrote ...

They ARE bad people if they are illegal, they are intentinally breaking our laws, why have laws if we don't enforce them? Send them back immediately, make it understood that if they aren't here legally they aren't welcome, if we didn't "look the other way" this wouldn't have happened, when they find out they will be shipped back when caught they would go through the proper channels to come to the USA legally, they need to learn English and stop breaking the law, it's as simple a that.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 7:26 PM jimbo wrote ...

To rlr -- You're not helping when it takes more money to support you than you contribute to society. If you're not paying 1/3 of your salary in taxes...you're not helping. You are a burden on society. All Americans are required to pay income taxes. Are you paying income taxes? And that remark about people too lazy to do jobs...it's pretty ungrateful.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 6:39 PM rlr wrote ...

everybody is ignorant!!! we are here to work and help your country business. we do jobs that some people are lazy to do!!!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 2:57 PM No name wrote ...

that is a good comment"if you don't want them here, why don't you work their jobs and maybe you woulds start thinking different about them and the work they do. What about the Irish and all the other nationalities when they came over here, the same comments were made about them. Our ancestors came over here for religious freedom and to find a better life, just like these people are doing. Make it easier for them to get citizenship or whatever.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 1:43 PM mmmmm wrote ...

My family's car was struck by a red-head. The accident left my mother in a coma for 6 months. Therefore, I'm anti-red-head. Peace.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 12:32 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I just don't understand why the gov let her go and didn't already charge her.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 11:56 AM Anon wrote ...

No one is saying they are bad people, just that a tragedy could have been avoided if she would have been deported after any of her first 3 offenses. How she was arrested for all those things previously and never deported baffles me. Obviously something is wrong with the system. People like the Kilborns need to stand up for that belief. Everyone should be treated well, but take care of our own first, then worry about everyone else

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 11:32 AM Barbara wrote ...

Chances are she is back in the country already, with another fake license and someone else's ID. It might even be YOURS.....

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 11:28 AM Anonymous wrote ...

What is wrong with you people??? Where did this article state that this couple is against people immigrating over here? Their ONLY request is that they be here legally. WHY is that so difficult to comprehend?

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 11:22 AM Anonymous wrote ...

TO JAKE it doesnt matter if if was unrelated they are criminals and dont belong they could of been hit by anybody but the anybody that hit them didnt belong here and wouldnt of hit them had they not been in our country illegally or even in jail where all drug users belong THE LAW IS THE LAW!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 11:08 AM jake wrote ...

your comments remind me of what your ancestors were descibed as. So in the end you would have been no better than those who treated your own family like dirt. Its too bad your ancestors had anchor babies also because now you're here. Also you ancestors brought over diseases that can be PROVEN that killed off the natives, oh wait thats a blanket statement and pretty ignorant kind of like your own statement!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 10:33 AM Whisky_NW wrote ...

A criminal is a criminal. They came to our country illegally and live here illegally. The law seems to be optional for them. For the most part they pay no taxes. You're required by law to have car insurance to drive in Iowa, but I can't imagine why that would, in their mind, apply to them. If they are here illegally, they're criminals. Catch them, send them back, fine them, jail them, and let them know that until they can follow the rules, they're simply not welcome. Have a nice day.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 10:33 AM Hey No Name wrote ...

Why don't we get rid of welfare and let those people work at the meat packing plants.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 10:24 AM GMO wrote ...

To JAKE.. Yes they could have been hit by anyone,yes thats true but they were not,She is a illegal,a crimminal who I'm sure has no remorse for other then she got caught.It was good reporting,it is the very sole of this problem. This woman is illegal, a past criminal,this woman needs to be in jail in her own country and pay restitution for her actions. It is all related!! Not all immigrants are drugies and beat there kids but this lady is, so I'm not just going to disregard it!DEPORT to jail!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 10:12 AM Ridiculous wrote ...

Come on.....Anyone could have hit this car. But lets over blow it and make it a big deal because they were hispanic. Why didnt they raise a big stink about this when it happened...Why NOW all the sudden. Whites,blacks,asains and hispanic........They didnt run into you and hit you and kill someone simply because they were hispanic. That is pure idiotism!!!!!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 10:01 AM Quit sticking up for the illegals wrote ...

Someone commented that anyone could have hit them. Ok..the driver was illegal. If a driver that was drunk or had a suspended license hit them, they would have been punished. Quit sticking up for these illegal losers! Go live in Mexico if you're so supportive of their actions. To the family in this story, I am sorry for your loss, and I agree with you 100%.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 9:59 AM To amlccat wrote ...

amlccat - You better figure out your politics here. Bush and Congress both being responsible is an oxymoron. Congress and Senate are both liberal, which allows this cheap labor and illegals to happen from "rights." Bush is conservative and is opposed to illegals, but is consistently over-ridden by a liberal Congress and Senate. If you want to see a lot more of this (rights for illegals), liberal is the way to go in the upcoming election. If not, conservative is your best bet. Think hard!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 9:49 AM Anonymous wrote ...

Too bad previous criminal record in the article. HOWEVER, go try to live in Canada, better yet, try to be ILLEGAL in Canada so why can't we control our immigration from the south? I have no problem with people applying for a green card to come work here but enforce at least that much... do we have to have the Alamo AGAIN? This time Mexico would win.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 9:29 AM Missing the point wrote ...

You all miss the point of the story is to show you just another way illegal immigration effects us all on a daily level and how looking the other way cant continue. Had she been here legally she might have taken a test for driving and if she cant speak english how she suppose to read our traffic signs. And mention of the prior only show complacentecy of the local LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS!! HA Only the one they choose to randomly enforce. The criminal Justice system in this Country is a FARCE!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:59 AM To Jake wrote ...

I don't think the point of mentioning the other run-ins with the law that the lady had was to show that she has a drug problem or she abuses her children. The point was why the hell is she still here if she has already had 3 run-ins with the law!! The first one should have been enough to send her back to Mexico.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:56 AM Anon wrote ...

I'm not against people from other countries wanting to live in the U.S. legally but something must be done about ALL the illegal immigrants. Everybody says that they are good, honest people who just want to make a living and support their families..... How could they possible be honest if they are in this country illegally? They are here taking the jobs that we Americans used to have because they are willing to work at a much lower rate which is exactly what these big business people want.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:55 AM ILLEGAL wrote ...

Does no one seem to notice that the word "illegal" is in the name "illegal immigrants?" It doesn't matter if they are just honest people looking for an "honest" living, they are still here illegally and are breaking our laws. They should be punished accordingly. If they want to make an honest living, they need to come here the legal way and not apply for jobs with a stolen SSN!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:44 AM disgusted wrote ...

You bleeding hearts make me sick. Oh think about the illeagals, they are just here to work. One person died and two others were severly injured because someone was breaking the law and you want me to give simpathy to person who broke the law. If it was a drunk driver you would be screaming for his head. My nephew is joining the army when he graduates and comments like the ones here make me question why he should risk his life to protect some peoples freedoms when they don't even appreciate them.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:38 AM Anonymous wrote ...

I think america needs to take care of the legals first before we worry about how to help the illegals. Ship them back. I want my money to help those who came here the right way. We'd have more resources avalible if they weren't here. Let their own take care of them. My charity only goes as far as those that deserve it.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:30 AM RS wrote ...

This illegal killed someone and should be punished for it. One bad apple can spoil the whole bunch. We must get rid of all the illegals because they are ruining our way of life and our economy by driving up our costs like car insurance. Most illegals drive with none and no license as well. Why do you people keep defending them, they are law breakers. I hope someday one of them does something terrible to you so you will finally see the light.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:22 AM To No Name.. wrote ...

It is this very type of ignorance that keeps the flames fueled. There are plenty of LEGAL workers that do want and will work the jobs that are currently occupied by ILLEGALS! They must go after the employer that hires Illegal workers.It amazes me how some people think it is ok to pick and choose which laws are ok to break and feel that it should be over-looked by all! PEOPLE WAKE UP, IT IS NOT ABOUT RACE, IT IS ABOUT RIGHT AND WRONG! ILLEGAL IS ILLEGAL.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 8:11 AM Seriously? wrote ...

These criminals aren't pious refugees. They're coming here illegally, they're taking ID's illegally and in the case of the Kilborns, they took their loved ones life. No name, exactly what jobs won't Americans work at? If you take away the supply of workers the pay goes up and someone will do the job. Roy, if they're already breaking one law, what other laws will they break? Jake, if the other driver wasn't here there wouldn't have been an accident. A drug charge should lead to deportation.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 7:20 AM Anonymous wrote ...

A perfoect example of why the illegals must be prosecuted to the full extent of the law!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 6:49 AM lobosolo wrote ...

nice work Claire Kellett, its refreshing to see a story that is about the dangers of illegal immigration.

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 6:45 AM James Feickert wrote ...

Why aren't the companies Fine more!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 5:18 AM Anonymous wrote ...

too bad the people that want to work, ie Mexicans, are deported when we have such a big population of welfare slobs who will not work a day in their life..

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 1:05 AM lccat wrote ...

Again, as I commented on another article, "our" FAMILIES are at the mercy of ILLEGALS and their Anchor Babies being murdered, raped, infected with disease, or robbed. We can see the results of the ILLEGAL invasion in our courts every day! But NOT to worry the Chamber of Commerce will get their "cheap labor" increasing "their privatized" PROFITS, thanks to Bush and the Congressional Leadership!!

Flag for moderation

Thursday, May 15 at 12:13 AM jake wrote ...

Very sad but they could have been hit by anybody, American or not. Also I would have to point out that it is poor reporting to even include them saying that she had prior run ins with the law, UNRELATED, to traffic violations. It just fuels ignorance because most of those watching will relate drug addicts and child abusers to immigrants. So instead of thinking, they just break immig laws now they all beat kids and do drugs. BTW adopt kids from the US first, plenty need to be adopted here!!!

Flag for moderation

Wednesday, May 14 at 11:33 PM Roy wrote ...

I really feel sorry for there loss but lets not assume all illegals are bad people because of this single incident. They are good people who just wanna make a living like me and u and and every other person in this country.

Flag for moderation

Wednesday, May 14 at 11:31 PM No Name wrote ...

If you dont want them here than why dont you work there jobs maybe you might start thinking different about them and the work they do

Flag for moderation

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

By submitting a comment to this web site, I affirm that I have read, understand, agree to and shall abide by the following rules and regulations as a term and condition of all comments which I may post. As terms and conditions of using this KCRG web site, I agree that I am fully responsible for the contents of all statements which I make. To the best of my knowledge, all such statements are true, fair, and accurate. I shall not post any statements which attack a person’s integrity or moral character, expose a person to public hatred, contempt or ridicule, deprive a person of the benefits of public confidence and social dealings, or injure a person in the maintenance of that person’s business. I shall not knowingly post content that violates the copyright, trademark, patent or other intellectual property right of a third person. I shall not post content that is false, liable, defamatory, obscene, abusive, that violates a person’s right to privacy, that otherwise violates any applicable local, state, national or international law or that is otherwise inappropriate. I acknowledge that if I post a comment which violates this policy that an offended person to whom comments are directed may have a right through judicial process to determine my identity and make a claim against me for damages. I agree that I shall indemnify KCRG, its employees, agents, representatives and affiliates from any and all expenses KCRG may incur as a result of comments I post which violate this policy, claims and/or damages, including but not limited to reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. KCRG is not responsible for the contents posted or anything arising out of the use of the contents or other interaction and has no obligation or duty to monitor or control any posting but does reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove, or edit user generated comment.

Athlete of the Week
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
More On Demand

What's On KCRG

8:01
I Survived a Japanese
9:00
Primetime: The Outsiders
10:00
KCRG-TV9 News at 10
10:35
Two and a Half Men